Mike Gregory, Attorney - Mediation and Arbitration

Client Centered Dispute Resolution

Email | Phone: 940-387-1600 | Cell: 940-368-1656
Phone: 940-387-1600 Cell: 940-368-1656
  • Home
  • About Mike
  • Mediation Information
    • Mediation Overview
    • Mediation in Family Law
    • Mediation in Probate Cases
    • Mediation in Civil Cases / Contract Disputes / Personal Injury Cases
    • As a Mediator I Will Do the Following
  • Mediation Calendar
  • Gregory Negotiation Reports
  • Papers & Articles
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Gregory Negotiation Reports / Final-Offer Arbitration (FOA)

Final-Offer Arbitration (FOA)

July 24, 2014 By Mike Gregory

This week I read an article in NEGOTIATION BRIEFINGS, July 2014, Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School by Max H. Bazerman, Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School.  He discussed using final -offer arbitration (FOA) as way of putting “fair” offers to the test.  FOA is also known as baseball arbitration.  In FOA, each party submits its best and final offer to an arbitrator, who must select either of the two offers and not any other value.  The parties cannot appeal the arbitrator’s decision.

FOA could be used effectively in family law negotiations and mediations when the parties are too far apart on their offers and neither seems willing to move on the issue.  For example each side might be too far apart on the value of real estate, a business or on the percentage division of the community estate.  Let’s say wife places a value on the house at $300,000 and husband at $450,000.  Despite competing appraisals and their personal opinions, neither will give an inch on their values.  The lawyers or mediator could explain the concept of a FOA and that the mediator for this limited purpose would be the arbitrator (or they could select another person).  If the parties agree to use FOA, they face a real dilemma-one value will be selected, either $300,000 or $450,000 and it is not appealable.

FOA or the prospect of FOA causes husband and wife to get real and become reasonable.  They have a strong incentive to deliver an offer (value) the arbitrator would view as the most reasonable.  As Max Bazerman says:  “The logic and power of FOA is that the uncertainty it creates leads parties to reach agreement, avoiding arbitration and litigation.  In Major League Baseball, for example, teams’ and players’ uncertainty about what an arbitrator might decide typically drives them to reach agreement on contract disputes.”

The same logic applies in family law disputes if party A wants a 60/40 property split in A’s favor and party B wants the opposite.

The uncertainty of the FOA outcome pushes the parties to reasonableness, because they lose control of the outcome.  Similarly, the uncertainty, risk, stress and expense of no agreement and thus litigation should push parties to an agreement.  As I explain in mediations, today you have control over the terms of the agreement. However, you will have no control over the outcome of a court’s ruling.  I then tell them, “Going to court is like taking your favorite dog to a partnership between a veterinarian and a taxidermist.  The only thing you know for sure is that you will get your dog back.”

 

Filed Under: Gregory Negotiation Reports

About Mike Gregory

Mike Gregory

Mike Gregory, Attorney & Mediator
4524 Coyote Point, Denton, TX 76208-3237
Phone: 940-387-1600
Cell: 940-368-1656

Board Certified in Family Law by the Texas Board of Legal SpecializationDistinguished Credentialed by the Texas Mediators Credentialing Association

By the Way, Did You Read….

Cases Upholding Settlement Agreements

Reyes v. Reyes, No. 04-18-00012-CV, 2018 WL 6518794 (Tex. App.----San Antonio 2018, no pet. h.) (mem. op.) (12-12-18) Facts: Husband and Wife signed a handwritten settlement agreement and filed it … [Read More...]

Texas Supreme Court Case-Arbitration Clause in Attorney-Client Contract

Texas Supreme Court-No Legal Requirement for Attorneys to Explain to Prospective Clients Arbitration Provisions in Attorney-Client Employment Contracts-Husband failed to prove a defense to … [Read More...]

List of Reports

Mike Gregory Attorney & Mediator

4524 Coyote Point, Denton, TX 76208-3237
Phone: 940-387-1600
Cell: 940-368-1656

Legal Disclaimer
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. I invite lawyers and paralegals to contact me regarding mediation and arbitration. Contacting me does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to me until such time as I am hired for a mediation or arbitration.

Policy on Referrals

If you need legal services which I do not provide, I will refer you to at least two appropriately experienced lawyers, most likely lawyers Board Certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization. I will not receive a referral fee. --Mike Gregory

Contact Mike Gregory

To set up a mediation with Mike Gregory, fill out this form
or call the firm at 940-387-1600.

  • Email
  • Google+

Search This Website

MIKE GREGORY provides Mediation, Arbitration and Negotiation Services to attorneys and their clients all over Texas...

Denton County: Argyle, Bartonville, Copper Canyon, Corinth, Cross Roads, Denton, DISH, Double Oak, Elm, Flower Mound, Frisco, Hickory Creek, Highland Village, Justin, Little Elm, Krugerville, Krum, Lake Dallas, Lakewood Village, Lantana, Lewisville, Pilot Point, Ponder, Providence, Roanoke, Robson Ranch, Sanger, Savannah, Shady Shores, The Colony, North Lake, Celina, Trophy Club, Westlake, Paloma Creek, Oak Point, Coppell, Carrollton, Roanoke, Trophy Club

Dallas County: Dallas, Carrollton, Roanoke, Trophy Club, Farmers Branch, Irving, Richardson, Garland, Grand Prairie, Highland Park, University Park, Coppell

Tarrant County: Fort Worth, Haltom City, Arlington, Kennedale, Mansfield, Lake Worth, Azle, Watauga, Keller, Westlake, Grapevine

Collin County: McKinney, Plano, Allen, Anna, Celina, Farmersville, Frisco, Josephine, Lavon, Melissa, Princeton, Prosper

Cooke County: Gainesville, Valley View, Callisburg, Lindsay, Muenster, Lake Kiowa

Wise County: Decatur, Bridgeport, Alvord, Boyd, Chico, Rhome, Runaway Way, Aurora, Lake Bridgeport

Grayson County: Sherman, Denison, Whitesboro, Anna, Collinsville, Tioga, Pottsboro, Sadler, Gordonville, Van Alstyne

Harris County: Houston

Travis County: Austin

Williamson County: Georgetown

Copyright © 2019 Mike Gregory, Attorney and Mediator • • • All Rights Reserved

Web Design by The Crouch Group